Liquid Eyeliner vs. Pencil Eyeliner – Which is Better

It can feel like a never-ending mission to find the ideal eyeliner. The eyeliner comes in a variety of forms: liquid brush choices, liquid felt tips, pencils, gel pots, retractable and glide-on liners, and the list goes on and on. If you’ve been using the same eyeliner for years, it’s time to switch things up.

To ease things a little for cosmetic fans, newbies, and professionals to find out which products are the most popular, we have listed tips and tactics for selecting your new favourite eyeliner.

Liquid Eyeliner

If you’re a seasoned beauty fan, applying classic liquid eyeliner (with a container and brush) won’t be as difficult for you as it is for newbies.

Because liquid eyeliner is less forgiving if you make a mistake, you’ll need a steady, skilled touch.

You can’t beat the sleek intensity liquid eyeliner that helps you reach when it comes to practicing. Especially if you’re going for a winged look, it’s well worth the effort.

How to Maintain Eyebrows Shape at Home

Because of the dramatic colour payoff they provide, liquid formulations are the go-to for true cat eyes. Stick a piece of tape to the outer corner of your eyes before applying liquid liner, if you want to nail the winged eyes. You can make two even flicks by using the tape as a stencil.


Liquid eyeliner can create incredibly precise lines with the help of an experienced, firm hand. The precision of liquid can’t be duplicated by even the sharpest pencil.

Waterproof liquid eyeliner also features a pencil that can’t be beat for budge-proof staying power.

Fix your elbows on a smooth and steady surface when applying liquid eyeliner for exact perfection. For wobble-free lines, this provides you with a lot of control over your hand movements.

In almost every scenario, liquid eyeliner is deeper and more pigmented than pencil eyeliner.

As a result, a single stroke of eyeliner creates dramatic, attention-getting lines. It’s ideal for creating dramatic looks.

To create a smokey eye, combine the liquid with a pencil eyeliner. Begin by lining your eyes with pencil eyeliner and then layering on your eye shadow.

Blend out the darkest part near the lash line. Apply liquid liner very near to the lash line to really amp up the intensity of the smoky eye.

Felt Tip Liquid Liner

Everyone loves felt tip eyeliners, largely because of how handy they are. They’re simple to use, with a pen design that’s straightforward to handle and navigate.

How To Remove Kajal Properly Without Messing It Up

Liquid eyeliner with a felt tip is ideal for creating bold, sharp lines with a theatrical flair. Even a magnificent winged liner grows simpler with practice. However, if you’ve never used a liquid eyeliner pen before, you can end up with thick, smudged lines while attempting to smooth out the liner on both eyes. You’ll get there if you keep reminding yourself that practice makes perfect!

Pencil Eyeliner

Eyeliner in the form of a pencil is a timeless classic. Blend your pencil eyeliner across your lids for a sensual, smudgy effect, or keep it sleek and tidy to create an appearance that makes your eyes pop.

To avoid catching any liquid in her eyes, one respondent explains, “I always apply a pencil liner for my waterline.” Pencil eyeliner is simple to apply and may give you the smouldering lines you desire.

If you forget to bring your sharpener with you on excursions or keep it in your purse for touch-ups, you might be out of luck!

If you’re using a pencil eyeliner, a thinner line will give you a more natural look. Find a hue that complements your eyes if you’re willing to branch out from the black. Plums and purples bring out brown eyes, while blue-eyed ladies should pick Mac’s Pencil Eyeliner for a sexy but delicate appearance.

Retractable Pencil Liner

Sadly, retractable liners do not always come in the same colour range as regular pencil liners. They are, nevertheless, incredibly practical and minimize the need to constantly sharpen your eyeliner pencil.

Many retractable pencil eyeliners have a smooth, glide-on tip that makes application simple and precise. Retractable pencil liners, on the other hand, are not very durable. It’s possible that if you twist up too high and pull out too much of the retractable eyeliner at once, it’ll break.

Gel Liners

A third eyeliner recipe, known as a gel or cream liner, is also available, although it may be too complex for most people. Without daily usage, the gel solution dries rapidly and necessitates the use of a liner brush, either thin tip or angled. If you’re a makeup artist, you’ll appreciate how intense a good gel liner can be when using several colours.

How to Apply Kajal Thick and Bold Without Smudging

It is recommended that you look for an eyeliner that is healthy not only for you but also for the environment and your health, regardless of the type of eyeliner you choose, whether liquid or pencil eyeliner. Honest! beauty products are the greatest since they are clean, safe, hypoallergenic, and eco-friendly.

Pairing Liquid and Pencil Liner Together

The combination of a pencil and liquid eyeliner is unsurpassed for achieving the ideal cat eye.

Use a combination of tools if you like the colour of liquid liner but find it difficult to achieve a straight line.

Begin by tracing the contour of your eye and wing using a pencil. When you’re satisfied with the result, trace it with a thin liquid liner for added effect.


Because each has its own application and ability level, there are so many different varieties of eyeliners available. Pencil eyeliners, on the other hand, are the most simple and ubiquitous variety for everyday use. They’re easier to work with because there’s no liquid involved, and they glide effortlessly down the lash line to produce an equal look.

Most women make the error of not sharpening their pencils on a regular basis, and as a result, they do not achieve the ideal look.

You may avoid this problem by using a retractable eyeliner like the Lakmé Absolute Forever Silk Eyeliner, which has a silky creamy texture that rests pleasantly on the eyes and does not require sharpening.

Filed under: Makeup & Hair, Tips and Myths

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.